Carpet is cheaper upfront ($2–$8/sqft installed vs $3–$12 for laminate), but laminate typically lasts twice as long in high-traffic areas. This page does the 20-year total cost comparison that most flooring sites won’t, because they have an interest in selling you one or the other.
| Factor | Carpet | Laminate |
|---|---|---|
| Material cost/sqft | $1–$5 | $1–$7 |
| Installation cost/sqft | $0.50–$1.50 | $1–$3 |
| Padding/underlayment | $0.30–$0.75 | $0.20–$0.60 |
| Total installed/sqft | $2–$8 | $3–$12 |
| 12×12 room total (standard) | $605–$1,170 | $690–$1,725 |
| Typical lifespan | 8–15 years | 15–25 years |
| Cost per year (12×12 mid-grade) | $55–$115/yr | $42–$83/yr |
| Replacement cycle (20 yrs) | 1–2 replacements | 0–1 replacement |
| Room | Recommended | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Master bedroom | Carpet | Comfort underfoot, warmth, low traffic. Cost-effective and comfortable. |
| Children's bedroom | Carpet (nylon/triexta) | Soft for play, stain-resistant choices available. Low cost. |
| Guest/spare bedroom | Carpet (budget) | Low traffic, low priority. Cheapest adequate choice. |
| Living room (family/pets) | Laminate or LVP | Durability, easy cleaning, better for heavy use. |
| Living room (quiet household) | Carpet | More comfortable and cheaper if you don't have pets. |
| Hallways | Laminate or LVP | Highest-traffic zone. Carpet wears fastest here. |
| Stairs | Carpet | Safer underfoot, less noise, cheaper installation vs hard flooring on stairs. |
| Basement (dry) | Either viable | Carpet is warmer; laminate handles occasional moisture better. |
| Factor | Carpet | Laminate |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort underfoot | Soft, warm, cushioned | Hard, cool, less cushioned |
| Noise absorption | Excellent, absorbs foot noise | Moderate (needs quality underlayment) |
| Allergy suitability | Traps dust, dander, allergens | Easy to clean thoroughly, better for allergy sufferers |
| Pet scratch resistance | Snags on claws (esp. loops) | Scratch-resistant surface options available |
| Spill cleanup | Absorbs spills, staining risk | Wipe clean, much easier |
| Water resistance | Poor, moisture causes mould/odour | Water-resistant (not waterproof); LVP is waterproof |
| Resale value perception | Neutral to slightly negative (buyers often replace) | Neutral to positive |
| Thermal insulation | Better, warmer rooms, lower heating costs | Cooler underfoot; less insulation |
For detailed laminate pricing, types, and cost calculations, visit our sister site.
See laminatefloorinstallationcost.com →Send it over and a person reads it. We answer what we can answer, and every answer names what it rests on, whether that is a pad manufacturer’s specification, a wage series, or a retailer’s own published price sheet.